Brolo Cigars are only available through retailers. Support your local brick & mortar.

Joshua Stephens | Jan 13

The Second Worst Cigar I Ever Smoked; A Story About Cigars, Ego, and Brotherhood

We did it.

Well… some of us did.


Although it was borderline medieval torture, Shaun finished The Woody by Oscar, a 21x80 Honduran puro that takes somewhere between four and seven business days to smoke, depending on lung capacity and will to live. Patrick from Halfwheel clocked it at seven hours. Shaun looked like he’d aged seven years.


Me?

I made it twenty-five minutes.


Getting the thing lit required lungs forged in a CrossFit volcano. Someone produced a blowtorch like we were welding farm equipment. Even with all the right tools at my disposal, my head started pounding, my eyes watered, and my soul quietly whispered, “You don’t have to prove anything to these people.”


Then came the draw.

Or lack thereof.


After enough wheezing to qualify for a medical study, Shaun handed me his sacred relic: the PerfecDraw.


Now, one thing you should know about Shaun, the man loves cigars. Knows cigars. Owns cigars. Has gadgets for his gadgets. If cigars had a Costco membership program, he’d be platinum.


He calmly explains, “You gotta be careful with this thing, or you’ll punch through the wrapper and ruin the cigar.”


Naturally, I immediately ignored him.

Point. Center. Push.

Ten seconds later, my cigar turned into a flute.

A clean, glorious hole straight through the side.

Was I mad?

Nope.

I was relieved.


I tossed that log of suffering into the abyss, reached into my humidor, and lit something balanced… intentional… humane.


And I sat there smiling while everyone else committed to their bad decisions like war veterans.


I won’t lie…watching grown men suffer through a novelty cigar while I enjoyed myself was carnally refreshing.


And that’s when it hit me:

I didn’t want to smoke The Woody.


I wanted the idea of smoking it.

The story.

The photo.

The bragging rights.

The “remember when we survived this” badge.


Somewhere along the way, the experience became less about enjoyment and more about endurance.

Less about flavor…more about flexing.

Less about connection…more about completion.


It wasn’t a cigar meant to be enjoyed.

It was a cigar meant to be conquered.

And we do this with life all the time.


We romanticize things from a distance:

The job.

The title.

The relationship.

The lifestyle.

The business.

The version of ourselves we think we’re supposed to become.


We picture the highlight reel. The applause. The moment at the top of the mountain.


Nobody daydreams about:

The headaches.

The nausea.

The tools just to make it barely functional.

The quiet realization at hour three that you chose wrong.


Sometimes the dream is real.

Sometimes the dream is just a 21x80 mistake wrapped in good marketing.


Here’s the uncomfortable truth:

Quitting the wrong thing is often braver than finishing it.


Punching that hole felt like failure for three seconds.

Then it felt like freedom.


I reached into my humidor and grabbed something balanced. Something thoughtful. Something made with intention. Something that didn’t require suffering just to prove a point.


And suddenly everything was good again.

The reason I smoke cigars in the first place came back.

It’s about smoking the right thing.

The cigar that invites you to stay.

Not survive.


The kind that doesn’t dare you to endure…

but asks you to slow down.

Because there’s a difference between:

“I finished it.”

and

“I enjoyed it.”


Life’s too short to confuse the two.

Sometimes wisdom looks like grit.

Sometimes it looks like a hole in the side of a cigar, and the humility to choose better.


And here’s the truth:

There’s no medal for suffering through bad cigars.

No parade.

No sash.

No secret society whispering, “Thank you for your service.”


The real win?

Putting it down.

Lighting something better.

And rejoining your people.

Laughing while your buddies stubbornly commit to the bit.

Borrowing tools you don’t know how to use.

Roasting each other for rookie mistakes.


Watching grown men debate draw resistance like it’s constitutional law.

Not perfection.

Not endurance.

Not luxury cosplay.


Just shared smoke.

Shared stories.

Shared moments.


Preferably over something enjoyable.

And if you ever turn your cigar into a woodwind instrument along the way…


Welcome to the brotherhood.

Light Up & Lean In,

Joshua Stephens

More Posts

The Slow Burn:  BlacktopsThe Slow Burn:  Blacktops
The Slow Burn: Blacktops

When I heard “dress for the job you want,” I grabbed the flare cuts and snip toes, layered a tank under a leather jacket, and let the locks fly beneath a high-crown trucker hat. Aspiring to more than a normal nine-to-five, I was going to be a rockstar, come hell or high water.


And boy…there was quite a bit of hell and high water.


Touring the country is a lot more romantic on paper and film. You tend to capture the highlights: audiences singing along to your songs, road shenanigans, funny skits, packed rooms. High-energy dopamine hits delivered moment after moment.


But that’s not the full picture.


Dreams require sacrifice.


Like driving a tour bus through Iowa at 3:30 in the morning. Or getting a social media notification of wedding photos from one of your best friends...another wedding you weren’t able to attend, laid at the altar of dreams pursued.


You drift a little farther from your closest circle with each passing zip code.


You watch friends behind screens build lives. They get married, have children, buy houses, get promotions, while you’re washing jeans in a Love’s sink. But you tell yourself living as a musical gypsy is freer than surrendering to some construct built by “the man.”


Then the microwave beeps, waking you from the autopilot life has become. You grab your $2.99 burrito and head back outside.


A slave to truck stops and blacktops.


The show must go on at all costs.


The American Dream doesn’t feel so dreamy.


So you embrace the struggle, pursuing what could be.


But if you pay attention, there are beautiful moments between those yellow lines. A sunrise on the horizon kissing the tips of corn stalks. Stumbling onto a melody somewhere between miles of asphalt while the rest of the band sleeps. Windows cracked, wind rolling through a van full of exhausted souls singing Waylon Jennings at the top of their lungs.


Crowds responding to your art in unison.


The venues get bigger. Eventually, you’re not loading in anymore. Road crews take over. Things start looking a little more like the dream you imagined.


Yet somehow, in the middle of all that magic, you can still miss the forest for the trees.

The Slow Burn: Kansas City Cigar FestivalThe Slow Burn: Kansas City Cigar Festival
The Slow Burn: Kansas City Cigar Festival

Last week, several of the Brolos and I attended the Kansas City Cigar Festival. The festival was Saturday, but we decided to make a weekend out of it. Because apparently a bunch of grown men with an unhealthy amount of cigars can't simply arrive at an event, attend it, and go home like normal people.


We left Dallas around 6-ish Friday morning and pulled into Kansas City around 4:45 that afternoon. In between were gas stations, snacks, questionable decisions, lunch at Bite Me BBQ in Wichita, and a quick stop at Old Town Cigars. Shoutout to Old Town, by the way. They had an awesome selection of boutique cigars, including some of the old-school Metapas from before Foundation rebranded them as Aksum. Those aren't exactly sitting on every shelf anymore.


But I'm getting ahead of myself.


Shawn arrived at my place a few minutes late and blamed traffic. In his defense, he wasn't lying. 380 in the morning is a complete nightmare. North Texas has grown at a ridiculous pace, and it seems like no amount of construction can keep up. Every road is simultaneously being expanded and somehow getting worse.


We loaded Shawn up and headed to a bougie neighborhood in Prosper to grab Justin. We made it through the gate, pulled up to the house, and there he was...sitting in a camp chair, bags packed, already smoking a cigar.


It was a sight for sore eyes.


Naturally, we immediately started roasting him for not even making it to 6:00 a.m. before lighting one up. His defense was that he was "afraid he would be left out." Justin is the newest cigar smoker in the group, but the man put the first number on the board that weekend. Kudos.


Next up was Mr. Babyface himself, Mark. Picture this: it's roughly 5:30 in the morning and Mark is standing outside next to his truck, bags packed, looking like his parents just told him they were taking him to Disney World. Everybody was ready. And for the next eight hours, we absolutely destroyed my car.


Four men. A few boxes of cigars. Windows cracked. Ash everywhere. I don't think it will ever smell the same again. But that's the price you pay for making memories around something you love.


We put Justin in charge of picking lunch.


This was our first mistake.

The Slow Burn: MaineThe Slow Burn: Maine
The Slow Burn: Maine

A reflection on Maine and the fear, pressure, and freedom that come with finally letting go of something you created.

Heritage: Recently, I’ve been thinking quite a bit about heritage and what that word actually means to me.Heritage: Recently, I’ve been thinking quite a bit about heritage and what that word actually means to me.
Heritage: Recently, I’ve been thinking quite a bit about heritage and what that word actually means to me.

It’s an all-encompassing term.


There are the tangible things and the intangible ones. The personal and the cultural. Traditions, values, stories, recipes, land, names, beliefs, habits, and physical objects passed from one generation to the next.


Some things are handed to us intentionally.

Others just arrive.


Building Brolo has me thinking about heritage quite a bit.


The cigar industry, maybe more than most, loves heritage. Many brands benchmark their quality against generational pedigrees, old-world traditions, luxury positioning, or some combination of the three. Families who have worked with tobacco for generations. Names that stretch back a hundred years or more. Stories with roots deep enough to make whatever they're selling today feel connected to something much older.

And there's something beautiful about that.


But where does that leave a kid like me?


I didn't grow up with a mother and father.


There isn't some great family enterprise being handed down to me. I didn't serve in the Armed Forces, and the only time I was involved with law enforcement was usually in the back of a squad car.


What the heck is my heritage?


And if heritage matters so much, how am I supposed to compete with that?


So I started digging.


Not through ancestry records or old family photographs, but through the things that got me here. The memories. The scars. The people. The failures. The things I learned accidentally and the things life taught me, whether I wanted the lesson or not.


I started asking myself:


What makes Brolo, Brolo?


The first image that came to mind wasn't tobacco.


It was a hay bale.


I was probably six or seven years old.


During the summer, my Grandma would drop me off for a week at my birth mother's trailer in East Texas, back behind the Pine Curtain.


Every summer, I dreaded it.


My second stepdad was quite a doozy...a real piece of work. Abusive. Violent. Looking back now, I can see he was probably just an angry boy trapped inside a man's body.


But when you're six, you don't have that kind of perspective.


You just know you're scared.


They lived in the country....or, as East Texans pronounce it, the cunnnn-trrrryyyyyyyy.


The acreage seemed to stretch forever, with a little creek running along the back of the property. My mother worked all day as a nurse, and my stepdad worked as a carpenter, taking odd jobs here and there.

I don't remember him being particularly great at woodworking.


But the man sure knew how to rip a doobie.


Wherever they were, I wasn't.


Most days, I was on my own, traversing the countryside. Climbing hay bales. Jumping hay bales. Falling off hay bales.


And, eventually, crying next to hay bales.

I remember getting hurt out there once.

And I remember being angry with myself for getting hurt.


Scared because I didn't know if I'd be able to survive a sprained ankle, let alone another week unsupervised.


Broken because I was alone and hurting.

And nobody showed up that day to help me.


Although that was the first time I remember feeling it, it certainly wasn't the last.


Those experiences taught me independence.


Eventually, they also taught me control.

If nobody is coming, you learn to handle things yourself. You learn to anticipate problems. You learn not to need much. You learn how to survive.


Useful skills.

Until they're not.


Because somewhere along the way, independence can become isolation. Self-reliance can become control. And learning not to need anyone can leave you desperately wanting someone.


Maybe that's heritage, too.


Not everything passed down comes in a box.


A few weeks ago, I went to the doctor for a regularly scheduled checkup. Somewhere between the blood pressure cuff and the usual questions, she started asking about my family.


Heart disease?

Cancer?

Diabetes?

High blood pressure?


She was trying to understand my family history...to identify the things buried somewhere in my DNA that might eventually become part of my story.


In other words, she wanted to know:

What runs in your family?


It's a clinical question.

But I've thought about it differently ever since. Because a lot more than disease runs in families.


Work ethic runs in families.

Faith runs in families.

Temper runs in families.

Generosity runs in families.

Addiction runs in families.

The way we handle money. The way we argue. The way we love. The way we apologize....or don't. The things we celebrate and the things we refuse to talk about.


Somewhere along the way, all of it becomes inheritance.


We tend to romanticize heritage.


Grandpa's watch. Dad's old truck. Mom's recipe written in her handwriting. The family Bible with names and dates scribbled across pages yellowed by time.

And those things matter.


But heritage has a shadow side, too.


Some things are worth preserving.

Some things are worth restoring.


And some things need to end with us.


My childhood was a lonely one through no fault of my own.


As I got older, I started pursuing people.

At first, probably because I was afraid to be alone.


I was tired of being alone.

I was starving for belonging.

But somewhere in that pursuit, I discovered something much better than simply not being alone.


I found connection.


If this were one of my gospel-centered recovery pieces, this is probably where I'd spend the next thousand words talking about how human beings were created for connection.


And I believe that.


I believe true connection begins vertically...with God...and that healthy relationships with one another are a by-product of that relationship.


But that's another rabbit hole for another day.


Back to connection.


Because that's what Brolo is about.


Not heritage manufactured through some bullshit origin story.


Not luxury for luxury's sake.


Not pretending we've been making cigars since 1873.


Connection.


It's the early-morning text from a friend encouraging you to succeed while simultaneously making light of your many proclivities.


It's the random Tuesday-night HERF where, for whatever reason, the whole crew shows up, and you belly laugh until your face hurts.


It's an early-morning coffee where somebody finally stops saying they're "good" and tells you what's actually going on.


It's spending so much time smoking cigars together that you know your buddy's palate almost as well as your own. You know what he's going to love. You know what he's going to hate. And occasionally, you make a recommendation that he actually likes.


It's getting bombed by one of the Brolo's.


It's seeing the UPS truck turn onto your street....or maybe even chasing it down, and feeling that little dopamine hit because you know there's a box headed your way.


It's knowing that whatever ails you, somebody is rooting for you.


It's complete strangers finding each other in some random corner of Discord or Reddit, sharing a cigar through a screen, and eventually becoming friends in real life.


Those things probably don't sound like heritage.


At least not the way the word is usually sold to us.


There aren't any centuries-old family photographs.


No tobacco fields passed from father to son.


No crest.

No pedigree.


But maybe I've been thinking about heritage all wrong.


Maybe heritage isn't just about where you came from. Maybe it's about what you carry forward.


And maybe the things we weren't given are sometimes the very things we become most determined to give away.


I didn't inherit a great legacy of connection.


So I built my life around finding it.


And now we're building Brolo around giving it away.


Maybe that's my heritage.


Not the kind printed on the inside of a cigar box. Not a family crest, a famous last name, or some romantic story about generations of men who came before me.


It's messier than that.


There's some good in it. There's some bad. There are things I'm proud to carry forward and others I've spent most of my adult life trying to put down.


But all of it got me here.


And I suspect the same is true for you.


What's your heritage?


Not just where your family came from or the traditions you grew up with.


What did you inherit?

What runs in your family?

What did someone teach you without ever sitting you down to teach it?


What wounds shaped you?

What values stuck?

What traditions still matter?


What parts of the people who came before you can you see when you look in the mirror?


And maybe more importantly:

What are you doing with it?


Because at some point, we stop being merely the recipients of heritage.


We become responsible for it.

We decide what gets carried forward.

What gets restored.

What gets rewritten.

And what ends with us.


Heritage isn't just the story of the people who came before you.


It's happening right now.


In the way you raise your kids. The way you love your spouse. The way you treat your friends. The work you put your hands to. The things you make time for. The things you refuse to compromise. The table you build and the people you invite to sit around it.


Whether you realize it or not, you're leaving something behind.


When I think back to that little boy sitting alone in East Texas, hurt and scared and wondering if anybody was going to show up, I can't change his story.


Nobody came that day.


But I can decide what I do with what he gave me.


Maybe that's why showing up matters so much to me now.


Maybe that's why the table matters.

Maybe that's why connection matters.

Maybe that's why Brolo exists in the first place.


So maybe the better question isn't simply:

What's your heritage?


Maybe it's:

What will someone else inherit because you were here?


What impact have you made, or lack thereof?


And maybe that's convicting...if so...that was my intention.


Kaitlyn and I don't make cigars to avoid life. We make cigars to fully embrace it. The good, the bad...the hurt and the wins.


All around a shared smoke.

About This BlogAbout This Blog
About This Blog

I wrote this back in 2017 and never published it. I found it again. And reading the words of the man I was has been an uncomfortable experience. This post is a multipart post about shame and where we can find hope. Stay tuned for the next post in the series...

The Slow Burn: CallusesThe Slow Burn: Calluses
The Slow Burn: Calluses

Some things can only be learned the hard way.

As a writer, I wage a lot of wars against a blinking cursor.


I get caught somewhere between what I want to say and what I think people want to hear. And I’m beginning to believe that’s a dangerous intersection.


The Slow Burn: CurrentsThe Slow Burn: Currents
The Slow Burn: Currents
The ocean never asked where I wanted to go…it simply carried me. Life works the same way. Left unattended, our faith, health, relationships, and purpose all drift. Currents is a reflection on recognizing when we've wandered and finding the courage to swim back toward what matters most.
The Slow Burn: The Things We Love The Slow Burn: The Things We Love
The Slow Burn: The Things We Love

Beneath a Nicaraguan moon, hidden behind a mosquito net, tree frogs wage war against my sleep. Their calls echo through the jungle like ladies of the night working a truck stop, each one louder than the last. Halloween Moon Crabs scatter across the ground beneath our cabana. I have to pee...but I'm not getting out of bed. Nature can have this one.


The Slow Burn: Rearview MirrorsThe Slow Burn: Rearview Mirrors
The Slow Burn: Rearview Mirrors

We all have a collection of "if only" moments….roads not taken, mistakes we'd undo, opportunities we missed. But the longer we stare into the rearview mirror, the more likely we are to miss the blessings sitting right in front of us.